Trying to fix the negative control

on Monday, September 8th, 2025 12:57 | by Daniel Döringer

My previous JoyStick and T-Maze experiments revealed problems concerning our control groups. While control flies that were fed with ATR supplemented food avoided the light nicely, we also observed avoidance in our negative control who did not receive any ATR. In our experiments we use the CsChrimson channel, which should need ATR to be functional.
My hypothesis for why also our negative control now shows avoidance was, that some mutation in the gene encoding for the CsChrimson channel might have affected its sensitivity and now there was at least some residual activation, even without ATR.

As an attempt to identify the underlying problem I crossed new control flies, this time using NorpA;20xUAS-Chrimson flies from our stock. If there had been a mutation in the flies I used earlier the new flies should not show avoidance.

As of now, the results are hard to interpret. There seems to be also avoidance with the new flies, however this might also be due to low sample size. If increasing the sample size will only show more robust avoidance, we’ll have to think about other causes for the problem…

Update 17.09.25:

The flies used in the previous experiments unfortunately turned out to be not blind. I conducted a new set of experiments, this time with blind flies, and I also changed the light used to red light, at a peak intensity of 500 Lux.
With this setup the results look more like what we would expect from our negative control. Of course the sample size is too low for me to really be able to tell whether the negative control will not show a preference.

Update: 07/10/25: The results below were obtained from a new set of experiments. I reared new flies (this time the blind flies actually should be blind) and crossed them to Gr28bd-Gal4; TrpA1-Gal4 flies from our stock. If the problem was indeed the driver line, this negative control should not show avoidance. Its a bit early to say but for now it seems as I might be on the right track.

Category: Optogenetics

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.